What Is an Unreasonable Search and Seizure?
An unreasonable search and seizure happens when the government reaches into a person's body, home, papers, or belongings without a valid warrant, probable cause, or a recognized legal exception. The Fourth Amendment sets that rule. When police skip these steps, the evidence they collect may be thrown out of court.
The Fourth Amendment protects people from an unreasonable search or seizure by the government. It tells police to get a warrant before most searches. The warrant has to rest on probable cause and be sworn under oath. The South Carolina Constitution guards the same rights at the state level, in Article I, Section 10.
The drunk driving stop is one of the most common places these rules come up. An officer who orders a blood draw with no consent and no warrant may be crossing a constitutional line. State v. Shannon, discussed below, shows how one South Carolina court used these rules to throw out blood test evidence in a felony case.
Examples of Unreasonable Searches and Seizures in DUI Cases
Examples make the rules easier to see. Here are the settings where unreasonable searches and seizures come up most in drunk driving cases, in South Carolina and across the country.
Warrantless blood draws without exigent circumstances. A blood draw is a physical intrusion into a person's body. It qualifies as a search under the Fourth Amendment. In Missouri v. McNeely, 569 U.S. 141 (2013), the U.S. Supreme Court held that alcohol naturally leaving the bloodstream does not automatically create an emergency. The warrant requirement cannot be excused based on this fact alone.
Each case is judged on its own facts. The Court said so again in Mitchell v. Wisconsin (2019), which dealt with blood draws from unconscious suspects.
Traffic stops without reasonable suspicion. An officer must have specific, articulable facts suggesting a traffic violation or criminal activity before pulling a driver over. A stop based on a mere hunch – with no observed driving error or equipment violation – may be an unreasonable seizure.
Vehicle searches beyond the automobile exception. Even after a lawful traffic stop, officers cannot search every part of a vehicle without limits. The search must be tied to the reason for the stop. It must also be supported by independent probable cause.
Prolonged detention after the stop's purpose is complete. In Rodriguez v. United States, 575 U.S. 348 (2015), the Supreme Court addressed this issue directly. Officers may not extend a completed traffic stop – even by a few minutes – to conduct a drug-sniff or further investigation. Reasonable suspicion of additional criminal activity is required.
Breath or blood tests obtained through coercion. Threatening a suspect with harsher criminal penalties solely to force submission to a chemical test may render the consent involuntary. The test results may then be subject to suppression.
Case Facts: State V. Shannon (Orangeburg County, 2016)
South Carolina v. Shannon, Orangeburg County Court of General Sessions, Case No. 2014A3810700545 (filed August 9, 2016).
On February 16, 2014, Shannon and Eartha Lee Kennerly were traveling south on Bozard Road in Orangeburg County. Shannon drove through a stop sign, left the roadway, and struck an embankment. The vehicle overturned. Kennerly died from internal injuries sustained in the crash.
Shannon was awake and clear-headed but in real pain. Medics worked for about two hours to free him from the car and stabilize him. During that window, Officer Norton of the South Carolina Highway Patrol drove to Richland County to get a search warrant for a blood draw. A magistrate signed it. But the sworn statement behind it had no signature from Officer Norton, and it held only bare conclusions – no facts showing probable cause.
Acting on that warrant, medical staff drew Shannon's blood while he was hospitalized. This happened before he was placed under arrest. The results showed alcohol and cocaine in his system at the time of the collision. Shannon was later arrested and charged with felony DUI resulting in death.
Shannon filed a motion to suppress the blood test results. He argued that taking his blood without valid consent or a proper warrant violated both the Fourth Amendment and Article I, Section 10 of the South Carolina Constitution. The State conceded the warrant was invalid. However, the State argued that the felony DUI testing law let officers draw blood with no warrant at all. The court heard oral arguments on November 12, 2015.
The Legal Issue: Warrantless Blood Draw and the Fourth Amendment
The central question was straightforward. Did the warrantless, non-consensual blood draw violate Shannon's rights under the Fourth Amendment and the South Carolina Constitution?
A blood draw is not a routine police test like a roadside breath check. It pierces the skin and takes part of a person's body. The Supreme Court drew that line decades ago in Schmerber v. California (1966). A forced blood draw is a search and seizure under the Fourth Amendment. Because it is a search, the default rule holds: get a warrant, backed by probable cause, before drawing blood.
Exceptions do exist. Consent, a true emergency, and a search made during an arrest are the main ones. The government carries the burden of proving one applies. When none does, the evidence from the unlawful search can be thrown out. Shannon's case asked whether South Carolina's implied consent law could set the warrant rule aside for good.
The Court's Ruling: Blood Test Results Suppressed
The court granted Shannon's motion to suppress. Its reasoning followed well-established Fourth Amendment principles.
The Fourth Amendment states that "the right of the people to be secure in their persons . . . against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause." Drawing blood from Shannon was a search within the meaning of that amendment. As the Supreme Court stated in Birchfield v. North Dakota, 579 U.S. 438 (2016), blood tests are "significantly more intrusive than breath tests." They "require piercing the skin and extract a part of the subject's body."
The court first found the warrant invalid. Under the search warrant statute, a search warrant may issue only upon a sworn affidavit establishing grounds for the search. Officer Norton's affidavit contained nothing more than bare conclusions and was unsigned. The State conceded the defect. The warrant was "so lacking in indicia of probable cause" that law enforcement could not rely on it in good faith.
The court then asked whether the search could survive without a warrant. The State pointed to the felony DUI testing law again. That statute orders a person suspected of felony DUI to submit to chemical testing, "notwithstanding any other provision of law." The court held that no state statute can give less protection than the Fourth Amendment demands.
Under McNeely, the natural loss of alcohol does not create an automatic emergency in every DUI case. Instead, courts must evaluate each set of facts individually.
Here the facts cut hard against the State. Officers had about two hours while medics freed Shannon from the wreck. That was plenty of time to get a proper warrant. Police did try. They just did it wrong. The court held that the attempt itself killed any claim of emergency, because it showed a warrant was clearly possible.
Because the blood draw broke the Fourth Amendment, the exclusionary rule required suppression. Mapp v. Ohio (1961) settled that evidence seized in an unconstitutional search must be kept out at trial. This ruling sits squarely within the wider body of unreasonable search and seizure cases that enforce it. The court also found the draw broke Article I, Section 10 of the South Carolina Constitution.
Why This Ruling Matters for South Carolina DUI Defendants
State v. Shannon sends a clear message. A blood test is not automatically admissible in a South Carolina DUI prosecution. Constitutional protections apply even in the most serious felony cases, including those involving a fatality.
No one should assume the evidence is airtight. Officers make mistakes. Warrants carry defects. Consent is sometimes pushed, or never given at all. When that happens, a defense lawyer can move to suppress the test results. If the motion lands, the State may lose its best proof.
Every case turns on its own facts. What matters is what the officer did, when, and whether each step followed the rules. Anyone facing a drunk driving charge in South Carolina that involves a blood draw should talk with a lawyer who can walk through the arrest and the testing.
How This Case Fits a Larger Body of Unreasonable Search and Seizure Cases
State v. Shannon did not arise in a vacuum. It sits within a line of U.S. Supreme Court decisions that have shaped modern DUI blood-draw law over the past six decades.
Schmerber v. California (1966) settled that a forced blood draw is a search. The Court allowed the warrantless draw there because the officer faced a real emergency: the suspect was already at a hospital after a crash, and waiting would have destroyed the proof. Schmerber did not hand police a blanket pass on warrants.
Missouri v. McNeely (2013) made that point plain. The Court rejected the idea that alcohol leaving the bloodstream is always an emergency. Judges must weigh the whole set of facts in each case and ask whether a warrant was possible.
Birchfield v. North Dakota (2016) drew a sharp line between breath tests and blood tests. A breath test can follow a lawful drunk driving arrest with no warrant. A blood test cannot, unless there is an emergency or valid consent, because it reaches so much further into the body.
Mitchell v. Wisconsin (2019) addressed the narrow situation of an unconscious DUI suspect. A plurality of the Court held that exigent circumstances will almost always justify a warrantless blood draw from an unconscious driver. However, the suspect may still challenge the reasonableness of the search on remand.
South Carolina's implied consent statute works alongside these constitutional protections. It does not replace them. A driver is treated as having consented to chemical testing by using South Carolina's roads. That driver still keeps the right to challenge an unreasonable seizure of blood evidence.
Police DUI Testing Procedures in South Carolina
South Carolina officers use three main tools on a drunk driving stop. Knowing each one, and the limits on it, helps a driver know their rights.
Standardized field sobriety tests. At the roadside, officers usually run the eye-tracking test, the walk-and-turn, and the one-leg stand. These are watching tests, not chemical tests, so the implied consent law does not cover them. How a driver did can be challenged on uneven pavement, bad lighting, or a physical problem.
Breath tests (DataMaster DMT). South Carolina uses the DataMaster DMT device for breath testing. It is typically administered at the police station or detention center after arrest. Under Birchfield, a breath test may be conducted incident to a lawful DUI arrest without a separate warrant. However, the arrest itself must be supported by probable cause.
Blood tests. A blood test is the most intrusive police test available. The breath and blood test statute lets an officer ask for blood when a breath test cannot be done. An officer may also ask for blood when there is probable cause to believe a felony DUI occurred. After McNeely and Birchfield, a warrant is generally needed, and a recognized exception must apply.
A note on wording. South Carolina charges this offense as driving under the influence, or as driving with an unlawful alcohol concentration. The state has no "DWI" charge at all. A driver searching for a DWI blood test in South Carolina is looking for the same thing described here, and the Fourth Amendment rules are the same either way.
When a Blood Test May Be Challenged as an Improper Search and Seizure
Not every DUI blood draw will survive a constitutional challenge. Defense attorneys may raise several grounds to argue that a blood test constitutes an improper search and seizure.
Absence of a warrant with no valid exception. If officers drew blood without first obtaining a warrant, and they cannot point to exigent circumstances, valid consent, or another recognized exception, the test results may be suppressed.
Coerced consent. Consent must be voluntary. If an officer threatened enhanced criminal penalties, implied that refusal would be treated as guilt, or used physical intimidation to obtain agreement, the consent may be deemed involuntary.
Lack of probable cause for the underlying stop or arrest. A blood test flows from an arrest. The arrest flows from a traffic stop. If the initial stop lacked reasonable suspicion – or the arrest lacked probable cause – the blood draw may be fruit of the poisonous tree.
Procedural errors under the implied consent statute. South Carolina's implied consent rules carry specific duties. The driver has the right to additional independent testing by a qualified person of their own choosing, at their own cost. A separate statute also requires officers to videotape parts of the DUI stop and the breath test site. Missing those steps can give further grounds for suppression, though the outcome turns on the facts of each case.
Talk With a South Carolina DUI Defense Attorney About Your Blood Test
If you are facing a DUI charge in South Carolina and your case involves a blood draw, the results of that test are not necessarily the final word. State v. Shannon demonstrates that blood evidence can be suppressed when law enforcement fails to follow constitutional requirements.
Sumner & Todd, Attorneys at Law reviews every step of the stop, the arrest, and the testing for Fourth Amendment problems. Officers need a valid warrant or a recognized exception before drawing blood. Where they skipped the warrant, pressed for consent, or missed a step the statute requires, those gaps can become the base of a motion to suppress.
Contact Sumner & Todd, Attorneys at Law for a free consultation. Call before speaking further with law enforcement about your case. The sooner a defense attorney reviews the facts, the stronger your position may be.
Frequently Asked Questions About DUI Blood Tests and Search & Seizure
What Is an Unreasonable Search and Seizure Under the Fourth Amendment?
An unreasonable search and seizure happens when the government reaches into a person's body, property, or privacy with no valid warrant, no probable cause, and no recognized exception. In drunk driving cases it usually shows up as a blood draw taken without proper authority. Evidence from that kind of search can be kept out of trial under the rule set in Mapp v. Ohio.
Can Police in South Carolina Take a Blood Test for DUI Without a Warrant?
Generally, no. After Missouri v. McNeely and Birchfield v. North Dakota, a warrant is needed for a DUI blood draw unless there is an emergency or another exception. South Carolina's implied consent law does not outrank the Fourth Amendment. Officers have to show that getting a warrant was not workable on the facts before a warrantless draw will stand.
What Happens If a DUI Blood Test Is Suppressed in South Carolina?
If the judge grants the motion, the blood test results cannot be used at trial. Depending on what is left, the State may have to cut the charge, offer a better plea, or drop the case. Suppression does not end a case by itself, but it takes away what is often the State's best proof.
What Are Examples of Improper Search and Seizure in a DUI Case?
Common examples include a warrantless blood draw with no emergency and a traffic stop made on a hunch. Others are a car search that runs past what the stop allowed, and a stop dragged out past its purpose. A chemical test won by threat or pressure is improper too. Each one is judged on its own facts.
Does South Carolina's Implied Consent Law Let Police Draw Blood Without Consent?
South Carolina's implied consent law treats drivers as having agreed to chemical testing by driving on state roads. However, this statutory consent does not eliminate the Fourth Amendment's warrant requirement for blood draws. A driver may still challenge a blood draw as unconstitutional if officers failed to obtain a warrant and no recognized exception applied.